OpenTheo

Q&A#36 Was Israel Wrong to Ask for a King?

Alastair Roberts

Q&A#36 Was Israel Wrong to Ask for a King?

September 1, 2018
Alastair Roberts
Alastair Roberts

Today's question: "Was it a sin for Israel to ask for a king? 1 Sam 8 makes it seem so. But then Deut 17 seemingly gives permission for Israel to ask for a king. How should we think about Israel's monarchy? Should it have happened, or is it an example of an evil that God used for good?"

The post on Solomon that I mention in the video can be found here: https://theopolisinstitute.com/article/exodus-in-1-kings/.

If you have any questions, you can leave them on my Curious Cat account: https://curiouscat.me/zugzwanged.

If you have enjoyed these videos, please tell your friends and consider supporting me on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/zugzwanged.

My new Soundcloud account is here: https://soundcloud.com/alastairadversaria. You can also listen to the audio of these episodes on iTunes: https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/alastairs-adversaria/id1416351035?mt=2.

Share

FacebookTwitterRedditCopy Link

Transcript

More on OpenTheo

#213 Which Bible Translation is the best one? (Replay)
#213 Which Bible Translation is the best one? (Replay)
Ask NT Wright Anything
April 4, 2024
Listeners ask questions on which Bible translations we should deem as the best ones and which ones we should use on a daily basis. What makes a good t
The Transfiguration of Christ (with Patrick Schreiner)
The Transfiguration of Christ (with Patrick Schreiner)
Alastair Roberts
March 21, 2024
Patrick Schreiner joins me to discuss his wonderful new book, 'The Transfiguration of Christ: An Exegetical and Theological Reading': https://amzn.to/
Are the Crusades Proof That Christians Are Evil?
Are the Crusades Proof That Christians Are Evil?
#STRask
May 16, 2024
Questions about how to respond to someone who says the Crusades are proof Christians are evil, the facts around the church burning people at the stake
The Pastor as Leader with John Currie
The Pastor as Leader with John Currie
Life and Books and Everything
April 17, 2024
With everything the pastor must do—preach, pray, visit, raise money, organize meetings, write emails, study, write, marry, bury, and baptize—does he a
#210 The Problem of Evil and Suffering: questions with NT Wright (Replay)
#210 The Problem of Evil and Suffering: questions with NT Wright (Replay)
Ask NT Wright Anything
March 7, 2024
In today's Episode theologian and historian Tom Wright looks at listener questions on one of the biggest topics and questions the Christian faith face
#214 Is the Old Testament history or metaphor? (Replay)
#214 Is the Old Testament history or metaphor? (Replay)
Ask NT Wright Anything
April 11, 2024
Tom answers listener questions about the Old Testament. Can the truly trust the Old Testament? When was it all written? Is the Old Testament more spir
Is There Something I Can Do to Develop Love for Christ if I Am Emotionally Detached?
Is There Something I Can Do to Develop Love for Christ if I Am Emotionally Detached?
#STRask
March 14, 2024
Questions about whether there is something a person can do to develop love for Christ if they are emotionally detached and whether one should stay in
Fatherlessness and Mass Shootings
Fatherlessness and Mass Shootings
For The King
March 27, 2024
What does fatherlessness have to do with mass shootings? Surprisingly, a whole lot! Samuel's Substack: https://samuelbornman.substack.com/p/save-the
How Should I Respond to Someone Who Is Word-Faith and Believes in a Second Baptism of the Holy Spirit?
How Should I Respond to Someone Who Is Word-Faith and Believes in a Second Baptism of the Holy Spirit?
#STRask
April 25, 2024
Questions about how to respond to someone who is Word-Faith and believes in a second baptism of the Holy Spirit and what the Bible is saying about how
Has Apologetics Had a Positive Effect on Our Culture?
Has Apologetics Had a Positive Effect on Our Culture?
#STRask
April 4, 2024
Questions about whether apologetics has had a positive effect on people and our culture, whether the longtime privatization of our Christian faith has
What Constitutes a Marriage?
What Constitutes a Marriage?
#STRask
March 21, 2024
Questions about what constitutes a marriage, at what point God considers a committed relationship to be a marriage, whether the freedom to pursue marr
Where Have All the Fundamentalists Gone?
Where Have All the Fundamentalists Gone?
Life and Books and Everything
March 6, 2024
With two smart British historians—one from Oxford (Andrew) and one from Aberystwyth (David)--and one curious American pastor (Kevin), you might say th
Finding the Validity of the Resurrection of Jesus
Finding the Validity of the Resurrection of Jesus
Risen Jesus
May 2, 2024
In this episode, Dr. Licona discusses his process for finding the validity of the resurrection while writing his book, “The Resurrection of Jesus: A N
Before You Argue for God from the Existence of Evil, You Have to Prove Evil Exists
Before You Argue for God from the Existence of Evil, You Have to Prove Evil Exists
#STRask
April 15, 2024
Questions about the need to prove evil exists before arguing for the existence of God from the existence of evil and what to say to an eleven-year-old
Are We Only Interpreting the Bible This Way Because of Our Post-Enlightenment Way of Thinking?
Are We Only Interpreting the Bible This Way Because of Our Post-Enlightenment Way of Thinking?
#STRask
March 7, 2024
Questions about whether we’re only interpreting the Bible according to authorial intent because of our post-Enlightenment way of thinking and whether